Does Premier League VAR problem after day of controversy?
It was a day of supervisors differing over the right utilization of the video colleague ref as a few Premier League games hurled disputable choices on Saturday.
West Ham were denied a 90th-minute balancer when Maxwel Cornet's work was precluded after Jarrod Bowen was decided to have fouled Edouard Mendy in the development - a choice David Moyes called "outrageous".
Somewhere else, Newcastle saw what Eddie Howe called a "entirely great objective" chalked off and Leeds supervisor Jesse Marsch was shipped off for his response to two punishment choices that didn't go his side's way in that frame of mind by Brentford.
Premier League VAR problem
"Players and supervisors have been let down today, it's been a horrible day - they have been let somewhere near choices like that," said Alan Shearer on Match of the Day.
Previous first class supervisor Tony Pulis said on BBC Radio 5 Live: "It's not VAR - let me get this right. VAR simply records the TV film, individuals are running VAR.
"Those individuals are settling on the choices. It's the refs caught in that office, any place they are, pursuing the choices."
There was one example, nonetheless, of a ref being told to counsel the pitchside screen and staying with their on-field choice.
Premier League VAR problem details
That came at Nottingham Forest, where Michael Oliver granted a punishment for handball and - after five minutes - it was scored by Brennan Johnson.
"Great Michael Oliver, finally a ref has had the guts to say 'I'm staying with my choice'," said Shearer. "Expect to see a greater amount of that before very long in light of the fact that he is quick to make it happen."
Tyrick Mitchell transformed the ball into his own net and official Michael Salisbury precluded it for a foul by Joe Willock on goalkeeper Vicente Guaita, however Newcastle felt the midfielder was himself moved by Mitchell.
"I didn't figure it ought to have been refused, by and by, I thought it was a foul or a push on Joe Willock in the development to the ball coming in," said Howe.
"Joe's energy is fixed by then from his adversary, it then, at that point, conveys him into the goalkeeper. Yet, without that push, it's absolutely impossible that that Joe would have gone in with that power.
Premier League VAR problem statements
"Regardless, it's a punishment on the off chance that it's anything but an objective, so I was extremely shocked with the result."
Royal residence supervisor Patrick Vieira conflicted: "It was an unmistakable foul and on the off chance that it wasn't the guardian gets the ball in his grasp. The official pursues the best choice."
Shearer said: "It is stunning, wretched, shameful - Willock will head that ball, so Mitchell pushes him - Michael Salisbury takes care of business, it is Lee Mason [VAR official] who some way or another peculiarly tells him 'you have made a howler'."
Shearer said that the ref was then not shown the best point of the occurrence.
"Lee Mason is the one to fault since it is an unpracticed arbitrator," added Shearer. "At this level you must get that choice right, he has had no assistance from VAR. Very numerous mistakes, VAR isn't the issue, individuals are running it."
It was a story of two punishments in Brentford's 5-2 win over Leeds - one given, and one not.
Ivan Toney opened the scoring with a punishment, granted after a foul by Luis Sinisterra - who was considered by VAR to have the ball however taken the player first - yet Leeds were denied a spot-kick of their own when Crysencio Summerville was brought somewhere near Aaron Hickey.
"I must sort out some way to have conversations with the association or with refs to assist with understanding how a few choices get made," said Leeds manager Marsch, who was baffled the authorities didn't survey the test on Summerville.
Premier League VAR problem resolved
"I was talking with the fourth authority, attempting to be as deferential as possible, in any event, when a punishment was given that I presumably didn't believe was a punishment.
"And afterward you don't see it responded, the regard. That is my idea of it. That absence of VAR visit, eventually to me, is an absence of regard."
"I grasp his dissatisfaction," said Danny Murphy on Match of the Day. "It was a dreadful choice, upgraded by the reality Brentford had got one - you are anticipating that VAR should advise him to proceed to look and they don't."
Brentford manager Thomas Frank, in the mean time, had an alternate view: "I trust VAR and the refs to take a choice on that one. I saw our own one back after the game and it's an unmistakable punishment."
It was a sensational completion at Stamford Bridge as Chelsea retaliated to win 2-1 against West Ham, however the Hammers were denied a late leveler.
Chelsea manager Thomas Tuchel said he thought there was a foul on his goalkeeper before Michail Antonio put West Ham ahead yet concurred with the choice to deny Cornet's late strike for the guests.
Premier League VAR problem revealed
"We were fortunate today to get the VAR choice in support of ourselves, which was for me the right choice," he told Match of the Day.
Cornet jumped after Mendy parried the ball his direction, yet subsequent to being told to take a gander at the screen, official Andrew Madley concluded there was a foul on the goalkeeper by Bowen.
"The goalkeeper comes to take it, and really mishandles it none of his concern five or six yards, so he would never recuperate it," said Moyes, who added he was "humiliated" for VAR official Jarred Gillett. "Then he went about as though he had a shoulder injury. I'm astonished that VAR sent the official to see it.
"It was an incredibly terrible choice. I'd address VAR as much as the official, yet the ref ought to have adhered to his own firearms - there is not any justification for that not to be an objective, none at all. The miserable thing is this is the level of the powerless refereeing right now.
"Jarrod said he never contacted the goalkeeper. Also, assuming that you take a gander at it, he hops him. There could have been a following foot on the off chance that there was anything by any means."
Premier League VAR problem history
Previous Chelsea striker Chris Sutton said on Final Score: "I'm with David Moyes on that, the objective ought to have stood, it was anything but a foul on Edouard Mendy. This irritates fans all over the nation when they see choices like that. A flat out stunner."
Ex-Brighton striker Glenn Murray added on 5 Live: "Those are the choices that make chiefs go dark. I feel like Edouard Mendy has purchased that from the arbitrator."
What's more, Murphy concurred: "I don't think I have any words that I can say without holding back. It was a crazy choice - I can't track down any rationale in it."
Shearer said it was "never at any point a foul" and not why VAR was executed.
"Least obstruction, greatest advantage was everything that we were said when VAR was gotten," he said. "It is a horrendous, dishonorable choice - past awful."
Sony Bravia XR Master Series A90K